This post is also available in: Spanish
Recently, an online company hired freelancers overseas. One Brazilian contractor became unhappy about his compensation and publicly threatened to blackmail the company. The company was unable to resolve the issue and had to sue him in a Brazilian court. Finding a local lawyer for litigation in an unfamiliar legal system, with a different language, required extensive resources from the small online company. Brazilian courts are very sympathetic to workers, and will likely uphold the freelancer’s rights. The company might even end up paying more fines and awards due to the local law. The company’s attempt to reduce costs by hiring foreign freelancers resulted in a costly legal nightmare. Many companies that hire contractors from overseas don’t realize that they are suddenly exposed to more legal liabilities under foreign laws. Find out how to reduce the risks associated with hiring a foreign independent contractor below.
1. You will be penalized if your foreign independent contractor is legally defined as an employeeIf a US court or the IRS determines that a person your company hired as an independent contractor is in fact an employee, you can face liabilities for not meeting the requirements of employment. You might have to pay that person’s unpaid Social Security and Medicare taxes, worker compensation premiums, unemployment tax, and unpaid benefits, as well as interest and penalties on those payments. If the worker lives outside of the US, there could be even more liabilities under applicable local laws. For example, in EU countries, you might have to pay at least 4 weeks of paid vacation and holidays per year. In France, a bogus self-employment can bring up to 3 years of imprisonment and a fine for employers. Argentina and Peru have similar fines. An employee can be entitled to severance pay under the termination clause, while an independent contractor can be terminated without any additional compensation. Therefore, an unhappy contractor might pursue severance pay award in a local court, claiming his employee status. You will be shocked to learn that he is likely to get the award with sympathetic local courts and labor agencies around the world.
2. Make sure your contractor is not an employee under applicable foreign labor lawsDistinguishing an independent contractor from an employee is not always clear. In most countries (including the US), the written agreement is not a sufficient evidence of a principal-contractor relationship. Instead, countries often follow a list of factors to analyze the facts of the relationship. Even though different countries have different standards for testing a work relationship, they tend to look similar. For example, a contractor who works full-time exclusively for one principal is a de facto employee in many countries. It also becomes harder to defend a contractor status when he/she is employed for a long time. On the other hand, a contractor who provides his or her own office and supplies is more likely seen as an independent contractor, instead of an employee. In some countries, a contractor may not have non-compete, non-solicitation clauses added to their employment contract, because these are seen as evidence of employer’s control over the worker after termination.
3. Determine if your business has tax withholding and reporting obligations to the IRSIf a business hires an independent contractor in the US, it is required to report payment over $600 annually on Form 1099-MISC. However, the IRS has special rules for a business hiring contractors from foreign countries. Such businesses will not have any tax withholding or reporting obligations in most cases where a foreign contractor performs service outside of US. However, if a foreign contractor performs service in the US, certain conditions should be met to avoid tax obligations. Those conditions are:
- The nonresident alien performing labor services is present in the US for less than 90 days during the tax year
- The total pay does not exceed $3,000
- The pay is for labor or services performed for an office or place of business maintained in a foreign country
4. Have Foreign Contractors Complete IRS Form W-8BENEven though a principal does not have to report foreign contractor payments to the IRS in most cases, he should have a foreign contractor complete Form W-8BEN (for individuals) or W-8BEN-E (for entities). These forms are used to establish a status as a foreign person or entity. And your company is entitled to rely on the claims made on the form to determine tax reporting and withholding obligations. If the information in the form is different from the fact, and the worker does not qualify as a foreign contractor, the principal is not liable for not meeting tax requirements.
5. Comply with local tax agenciesIf a principal is not a resident of a country and has no permanent establishment in the country where the foreign contractor is a resident, there is generally no requirement to report or withhold taxes in the country. In addition, few countries require the reporting of contractor payments to tax agencies as the US does. However, a small number of countries have enacted laws to protect independent contractors. For example, France has designations called portage salarial and auto-entrepreneur for self-employed freelancers who are autonomous, but each of their principals may have to make payroll withholdings and contributions similar to those of a regular employer. In Spain, an economically dependent contractor who has one client from whom he devotes more than 75% of full-time effort is entitled to benefits, such as 18 days annual paid time off and severance pay. In order to avoid these unnecessary liabilities and penalties, it is important to talk to a professional who is familiar with the foreign country’s tax treatment of independent contractors before hiring. Additionally, it is a good idea to make sure that an independent contractor complies with the local tax requirements by specifying the duty in the work agreement, or asking for proof of tax compliance.
6. Have a written contractor agreement in placeA written agreement with a foreign contractor is an important step to specify terms of this unique work relationship. The agreement should clearly state the scope of services and compensation, to prevent future disputes. The agreement should establish a contractor status by showing independence and a lack of control in how a contractor performs the work. However, keep in mind that an independent contractor designation in writing can be easily challenged by applicable courts. Still, there are many reasons to have a written agreement with a contractor. In the US, independent contractors own the rights to the work done for the principal, unless it is transferred in writing. Many companies are unaware that copyrights stay with contractors by default, and often lose the rights to their most important intangible assets. Your company can prevent unfortunate incidents by having a clause to transfer the rights from a contractor to the principal. You might also consider adding clauses about how to resolve disputes when they arise. When multiple countries are involved in the work relationship, selecting governing laws and a forum in advance can save a great deal of time and resources in future litigations. Parties can also choose to have alternative dispute resolutions, such as mediation or arbitration, instead of lengthy litigations in courts. Make sure to check if the contractor’s country of origin requires the use of local laws and courts in the work agreement to protect their workers.
7. Consider hiring corporations or leased employees instead of independent contractorsYour business might be more concerned about the status of contractors when it expects to have certain control over them, or if the relationship becomes full-time and long-lasting. When the business is still not ready to hire them as direct employees, it can hire contractors who incorporated in the local country. A business-to-business contract is more readily interpreted as a contractor relationship in many countries. A business can also hire individuals as leased employees through a temporary agency, or a partner business in the country of origin, who hires them as employees. Then, your business can have a contract with a local company offering the services of a contractor.
8. Keep the day-to-day work relationship free of controlAs mentioned earlier, most courts look outside of the contract to determine the work relationship. So it is important that actual facts show that he or she was autonomous, without the principal controlling how and when the work is done. For example, having a work schedule determined by a principal, or having a training system or supervision, is not good evidence for protecting a contractor status. Long-term or continuously renewed contracts are also susceptible to challenges by courts.
ConclusionWorking with foreign independent contractors provides many advantages for growing businesses. By paying attention to the above issues before hiring, a business will be able to prevent costly legal troubles in the future. It is always a good idea to have payment and other work-related records in writing. If a business expects an extended relationship with a contractor, it needs to take further steps to consult local lawyers regarding labor laws, or hire the worker as an employee.
Contact Jiah Kim and Associates TodayCall our office to schedule a time to talk about a Business Audit Session, where we can identify the best ways for your business to prevent risks and maximize growth. This blog post is written for educational and general information purposes only, and does not constitute specific legal advice. You understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the blog publisher. This blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.
This post is also available in: Spanish